Coles Plus Saver vs Woolworths Everyday Extra
Grocery shopping can be a challenge for busy families, especially parents juggling young kids and tight schedules. With the rise of subscription services designed to help families save money and time, Coles Plus Saver and Woolworths Everyday Extra have become popular options. But which one is better for your family? In this detailed review, we’ll compare these two programs side-by-side to help parents decide which is the right choice for them.
Overview of Coles Plus Saver and Woolworths Everyday Extra
Both are subscription-based programs that offer discounts, rewards, and exclusive perks to frequent shoppers. They share similarities but also have key differences that can make one more suitable depending on your family’s needs.
Coles Plus Saver: What It Offers
Cost: $7 per month
Key Benefits:
1. 10% Off One Shop Per Month: Subscribers can enjoy 10% off one shop (online or in-store) per calendar month, with a maximum discount of $50.
2. Double Flybuys Points: Earn 2x Flybuys points on every purchase at Coles, First Choice Liquor Market, and Liquorland.
3. Exclusive Member-Only Offers: Access to special promotions and occasional freebies.
Best For: Families who shop primarily at Coles and want to save on larger monthly grocery hauls while earning rewards faster.
Woolworths Everyday Extra: What It Offers
Cost: $7 per month or $70 per year
Key Benefits:
1. 10% Off Every Month on Two Shops: Members receive a 10% discount on one shop at Woolworths and one shop at BIG W per month (in-store or online), with a maximum total discount of $100 per month.
2. Double Everyday Rewards Points: Earn 2x Everyday Rewards points on every shop at Woolworths and BIG W, both in-store and online.
3. Exclusive Subscriber-Only Free Products, Offers, and Promotions: Access special promotions and freebies tailored to members.
Best For: Families who shop at both Woolworths and BIG W and want to save on groceries and general household items like toys, clothes, and baby products.
Key Differences Between Coles Plus Saver and Woolworths Everyday Extra
1. Participating Stores
• Coles Plus Saver: Focuses exclusively on Coles and its affiliated liquor stores (First Choice Liquor Market and Liquorland).
• Woolworths Everyday Extra: Covers both Woolworths and BIG W, allowing for discounts on groceries and a wide range of household goods.
Who Wins?
Woolworths Everyday Extra takes the lead due to its inclusion of BIG W, ideal for parents shopping for kids’ toys, clothing, and home essentials alongside groceries.
2. Discount Application
• Coles Plus Saver: Offers 10% off one shop per month at Coles, up to a maximum discount of $50.
• Woolworths Everyday Extra: Offers 10% off two shops per month—one at Woolworths and one at BIG W—with a combined maximum discount of $100 per month.
Who Wins?
Woolworths Everyday Extra wins here, providing twice the opportunity to save with its two 10% discounts each month.
3. Cost and Payment Options
• Coles Plus Saver: Costs $7 per month with no annual payment option.
• Woolworths Everyday Extra: Costs $7 per month or $70 per year, reducing the effective monthly cost to $5.83 if paid annually. Additionally, Woolworths is offering a promotional discount of $35 for the first year for new subscribers (until 18 December 2024).
Who Wins?
Woolworths Everyday Extra is more cost-effective for long-term subscribers due to the annual payment option and promotional pricing.
4. Reward Points
• Coles Plus Saver: Earns double Flybuys points at Coles and affiliated liquor stores. Flybuys points can be redeemed for gift cards, discounts, and rewards.
• Woolworths Everyday Extra: Earns double Everyday Rewards points at Woolworths and BIG W. Everyday Rewards points can be redeemed for money off future shops or converted into Qantas Frequent Flyer points.
Who Wins?
This depends on preference:
• If you shop at Coles and value Flybuys rewards, Coles Plus Saver is ideal.
• If you want flexibility with points (e.g., redeeming for travel), Woolworths Everyday Extra is better.
5. Exclusive Perks
• Coles Plus Saver: Offers occasional freebies and discounts tailored to Coles shoppers.
• Woolworths Everyday Extra: Provides access to free products, personalized offers, and exclusive promotions at both Woolworths and BIG W.
Who Wins?
Woolworths Everyday Extra wins for variety, as the perks extend beyond groceries to toys, clothing, and household goods.
How to Decide: Which is Right for Your Family?
Choose Coles Plus Saver If:
- You’re a loyal Coles shopper and don’t frequently shop at other stores.
- You value Flybuys rewards and plan to redeem them for gift cards or discounts.
- Your shopping habits revolve around groceries rather than general household items.
Choose Woolworths Everyday Extra If:
- You shop at both Woolworths and BIG W and want flexibility in how you use your discounts.
- You’re looking for additional savings on toys, clothes, or household goods.
- You prefer the option to convert Everyday Rewards points into Qantas Frequent Flyer points.
- You want the most opportunities to save with two discounts per month.
My Personal Recommendation
As a parent, I find that Woolworths Everyday Extra offers more value for families. With its two monthly 10% discounts, double rewards points, and coverage of both Woolworths and BIG W, it provides a broader range of savings opportunities.
That said, Coles Plus Saver is an excellent choice for families loyal to Coles, especially if you regularly shop there and are already earning Flybuys points.
Final Thoughts
Both Coles Plus Saver and Woolworths Everyday Extra are excellent programs for families looking to save money and streamline their shopping. The best choice depends on your preferred store and shopping habits. With both priced at just $7 per month, you can easily try one (or both) to see which fits your lifestyle best.
Have you tried Coles Plus Saver or Woolworths Everyday Extra? Share your thoughts in the comments—I’d love to hear about your experience!
For more detailed information on Coles Plus Saver, check out our review here.
FAQ
1. What are the key differences between Coles Plus Saver and Woolworths Everyday Extra?
The main differences lie in the participating stores, discounts, and rewards programs:
- Coles Plus Saver focuses solely on Coles and affiliated liquor stores, offering 10% off one shop per month and double Flybuys points.
- Woolworths Everyday Extra includes Woolworths and BIG W, with 10% off two shops per month (one at each store) and double Everyday Rewards points.
2. Which subscription offers the most savings?
- Coles Plus Saver: Max savings of $50 per month from the 10% discount.
- Woolworths Everyday Extra: Max savings of $100 per month (10% off one shop at Woolworths and one at BIG W).
3. How much do these subscriptions cost?
- Coles Plus Saver: $7 per month, no annual payment option.
- Woolworths Everyday Extra: $7 per month or $70 annually (equivalent to $5.83/month). A current promotion offers the first year for $35.
4. Do both subscriptions offer rewards points?
Yes:
- Coles Plus Saver: Earns double Flybuys points.
- Woolworths Everyday Extra: Earns double Everyday Rewards points, which can also be converted to Qantas Frequent Flyer points.
5. Which is better for families with diverse shopping needs?
Woolworths Everyday Extra is better for families who shop at both Woolworths and BIG W, as it includes groceries, toys, clothing, and household items.
6. Can I use these subscriptions for online shopping?
Yes, both Coles Plus Saver and Woolworths Everyday Extra can be used for online and in-store purchases.
7. What exclusive perks do these subscriptions offer?
- Coles Plus Saver: Member-only discounts and occasional freebies.
- Woolworths Everyday Extra: Free products, personalized offers, and subscriber-only promotions.
8. Which subscription is better for loyal Coles or Woolworths shoppers?
- Coles Plus Saver is ideal for families who shop primarily at Coles and value Flybuys points.
- Woolworths Everyday Extra suits families loyal to Woolworths or BIG W, or those who shop across both stores.
9. Are these subscriptions easy to cancel?
Yes, both programs allow subscribers to cancel at any time, making them low-risk options to try.
10. Can I subscribe to both programs?
Yes, if your family shops at both Coles and Woolworths/BIG W frequently, subscribing to both may maximize your savings and benefits.
